Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-21 All About Eve - Women's Online Fashion | Online Shopping 0 views

Tarni Knit Top vs Aya Knit: Which Black Knit to Choose?

Tarni Knit Top vs Aya Knit: Which Black Knit to Choose?

Compare the Tarni Knit Top and Aya Knit in black. Discover fit, fabric, and styling differences to decide which knit top suits your wardrobe.

Two Black Knits, Two Different Fits

If you are shopping for a black knit top, the Tarni Knit Top and the Aya Knit are two options that look similar at first glance but serve different needs. The Tarni is a refined, fitted style with button details, while the Aya is a relaxed, cosy knit meant for easy layering. Here is how they compare based on fit, fabric, and intended use.

Fit and Silhouette

  • Tarni Knit Top: Designed with an on-body fit, the Tarni Knit Top is closer to the body without being tight. It has long sleeves and a functional button-through front, giving it a polished, structured look. The lettuce-edge hem adds a subtle detail that works well tucked or untucked.
  • Aya Knit: The Aya Knit offers a relaxed fit that is intentionally roomier. It is also long-sleeved but lacks shaping or closures, making it a true pullover style. The looser silhouette is ideal for a casual, laid-back look.

Fabric and Feel

  • Tarni Knit Top: Made from 80% Polyester, 16% Cotton, and 4% Elastane, the Tarni has a soft-touch, lightweight feel with stretch that holds its shape. The fabric is described as non-itch and feminine, suitable for sensitive skin. It requires a softener wash for care.
  • Aya Knit: The Aya Knit uses a blend of 59% Recycled Polyester, 22% Nylon, 10% Polyester, 8% Wool, and 1% Elastane. The inclusion of wool gives it a warmer, cosier hand feel, while the recycled content adds an eco-friendly aspect. The fabric is still soft but has more warmth than the Tarni.

Styling Each Knit Top

The Tarni Knit Top's button-through front and on-body fit make it a natural choice for layering under a blazer or wearing alone with high-waisted denim for a polished everyday look. Its lightweight stretch fabric works well for transitional weather.

The Aya Knit's relaxed fit and wool blend make it better for cooler days when you want a cosy, effortless layer. Pair it with jeans or leggings for a comfortable off-duty outfit. The lack of closures means it is a simple pull-on style that works as a standalone top or under an open coat.

Key Product Facts for Your Decision

  • Tarni Knit Top Black: The Tarni Knit Top is a refined wardrobe staple with a flattering on-body fit, long sleeves, and a functional button-through front. If you prefer a more structured, fitted look that can be dressed up or down, the Tarni gives you that versatility.
    Tarni Knit Top Black
    Tarni Knit Top Black
  • Aya Knit Black: The Aya Knit offers a cozy, relaxed fit with long sleeves and a wool blend for extra warmth. For a casual, warm layer that feels like a cosy sweater, the Aya is the better choice.
    Aya Knit Black
    Aya Knit Black

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose the Tarni Knit Top if you want a fitted, button-front style that works for both work and weekend outfits. Its lightweight, stretchy fabric and polished details make it a versatile staple.

Choose the Aya Knit if you prefer a relaxed, cosy pullover with a wool blend for cooler days. Its looser fit and warmer fabric suit a casual, comfortable aesthetic.

Both are available in black, so your decision comes down to whether you need a tailored knit or a relaxed layer.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile