Two Black Knits, Two Different Fits
If you are shopping for a black knit top, the Tarni Knit Top and the Aya Knit are two options that look similar at first glance but serve different needs. The Tarni is a refined, fitted style with button details, while the Aya is a relaxed, cosy knit meant for easy layering. Here is how they compare based on fit, fabric, and intended use.
Fit and Silhouette
- Tarni Knit Top: Designed with an on-body fit, the Tarni Knit Top is closer to the body without being tight. It has long sleeves and a functional button-through front, giving it a polished, structured look. The lettuce-edge hem adds a subtle detail that works well tucked or untucked.
- Aya Knit: The Aya Knit offers a relaxed fit that is intentionally roomier. It is also long-sleeved but lacks shaping or closures, making it a true pullover style. The looser silhouette is ideal for a casual, laid-back look.
Fabric and Feel
- Tarni Knit Top: Made from 80% Polyester, 16% Cotton, and 4% Elastane, the Tarni has a soft-touch, lightweight feel with stretch that holds its shape. The fabric is described as non-itch and feminine, suitable for sensitive skin. It requires a softener wash for care.
- Aya Knit: The Aya Knit uses a blend of 59% Recycled Polyester, 22% Nylon, 10% Polyester, 8% Wool, and 1% Elastane. The inclusion of wool gives it a warmer, cosier hand feel, while the recycled content adds an eco-friendly aspect. The fabric is still soft but has more warmth than the Tarni.
Styling Each Knit Top
The Tarni Knit Top's button-through front and on-body fit make it a natural choice for layering under a blazer or wearing alone with high-waisted denim for a polished everyday look. Its lightweight stretch fabric works well for transitional weather.
The Aya Knit's relaxed fit and wool blend make it better for cooler days when you want a cosy, effortless layer. Pair it with jeans or leggings for a comfortable off-duty outfit. The lack of closures means it is a simple pull-on style that works as a standalone top or under an open coat.
Key Product Facts for Your Decision
- Tarni Knit Top Black: The Tarni Knit Top is a refined wardrobe staple with a flattering on-body fit, long sleeves, and a functional button-through front. If you prefer a more structured, fitted look that can be dressed up or down, the Tarni gives you that versatility.

Tarni Knit Top Black - Aya Knit Black: The Aya Knit offers a cozy, relaxed fit with long sleeves and a wool blend for extra warmth. For a casual, warm layer that feels like a cosy sweater, the Aya is the better choice.

Aya Knit Black
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose the Tarni Knit Top if you want a fitted, button-front style that works for both work and weekend outfits. Its lightweight, stretchy fabric and polished details make it a versatile staple.
Choose the Aya Knit if you prefer a relaxed, cosy pullover with a wool blend for cooler days. Its looser fit and warmer fabric suit a casual, comfortable aesthetic.
Both are available in black, so your decision comes down to whether you need a tailored knit or a relaxed layer.



